Which QB Do You Choose In This Scenario...?

I'll take Brett Favre. I know he has a reputation for Gun slinging it, but I also think he can do more with less around him. I think Favre is tougher of the two QB's. When Favre lost in his second Superbowl appearance he outplayed Elway, but his defense couldn't stop the run. Warner in last years Superbowl played really well, but he also had some pretty bad moments that cost the offense.